Imagine buying stock in a company that has nearly tripled its revenue, only to learn that Wall Street thinks the stock could be valued between $80 and $265.
This is the unusual situation faced Palantir Technology(PLTR) investor.
On November 3, Citigroup analyst Tyler Radke raised the target price from $250 to $265 and maintained a buy rating.
Jefferies analyst Brent Thill came to a different conclusion. His company maintained an underperform rating and an $80 target, The Fly reported.
The price difference per share is $185, exceeding Palantir’s Nov. 3 closing price of $175.40.
That implies roughly 51% potential upside from Citi’s target, or 54% potential downside from Jefferies’ estimate.
Both companies assessed the same third-quarter numbers, showing sales growing 96% and demand for artificial intelligence software accelerating.
This creates difficulties for ordinary investors. How can a business do so well when Wall Street is so divided over its stock price?
The response reveals both Palantir’s situation and the price investors are prepared to pay for artificial intelligence.
Citi sees extraordinary growth in artificial intelligence business
Palantir’s Nov. 2 earnings report helps explain the enthusiasm among optimistic experts.
The company reported third-quarter revenue of $2.31 billion, a 96% year-over-year increase. Its US commercial business grew 148% to US$984 million, surpassing US government revenue for the first time at US$953 million.
This is significant because Palantir’s development no longer relies primarily on government and military organizations. The company’s addressable market is growing as more private companies pay for its AI-powered software.
Additionally, Palantir reported adjusted free cash flow of $1.22 billion and a margin of 53%. Management raised its forecast revenue for 2026 to approximately $8.53 billion, an annual growth rate of 91%.
Citi called the quarter “another revenue blowout,” citing strong government and commercial revenue, according to Yahoo Finance.
The bullish argument is simple. If Palantir continues to grow at a breakneck pace while maintaining high profit margins, its current value may one day appear more realistic.
The company also has financial flexibility thanks to $10.4 billion in cash, equivalents and U.S. Treasuries.
“Our overall business has essentially doubled since the same quarter last year,” Palantir CEO Alex Karp said.
However, as Jefferies’ targets show, a stock’s strong financial performance doesn’t always translate into an attractive price.
Bloomberg/Getty Images
Jefferies sees bigger valuation problem
Jefferies acknowledged Palantir’s strong results.
Its concern is whether the company can sustain such extraordinary growth as its revenue base expands.
More Wall Street:
- Nvidia and Micron are about to have success all over Wall Street
- Nvidia, Palantir and Alphabet take Wall Street by storm
- Wall Street elite to reap windfall from record $46 billion in profits
According to The Fly, Jefferies believes that Microsoft (MSFT), Oracle (ORCL) and Snowflake (SNOW) are better artificial intelligence investments due to their valuation and growth potential.
Examining Palantir’s market value makes this issue even more apparent. Based on the closing price on November 3, Palantir was valued at approximately $421.5 billion. That’s about 49 times Palantir’s projected 2026 annual revenue of $8.53 billion.
As a result, investors are paying not only for the company’s current profits, but also for its significant growth many years into the future.
This could be effective when sales and earnings continue to be higher than expected. But even if the business remains profitable, it faces risks when growth stops.
Companies that grow 40% or 50% a year usually get a lot of attention from investors. However, for a company as aggressively priced as Palantir, this could still be a major disappointment.
Jefferies isn’t saying Palantir’s AI technology doesn’t work. It questions whether shareholders are paying too much for that success.
Palantir investors face test of beating price targets
Jefferies’ $80 target and Citi’s $265 forecast are not set in stone.
Analyst targets reflect assumptions about future growth, profits and value acceptable to investors. These assumptions may change suddenly.
Palantir also strongly disagrees with this bearish view.
Its adjusted free cash flow rate is 53%, indicating significant cash creation coinciding with rapid expansion. Reuters reported that management expects fourth-quarter revenue of approximately US$2.65 billion, higher than analysts’ expectations of US$2.46 billion.
This enables investors to track quantifiable changes.
Is it possible that business income will continue to grow at such an astonishing rate? Can Palantir maintain strong margins as it expands? Can future profits support the current market valuation of more than $400 billion?
These issues go beyond choosing the right analyst.
Shareholders who purchased Palantir at a much lower price would have to make different choices than shareholders who were considering a new acquisition at around $175.
The first investor may have substantial profits to protect, while the second investor needs enough future growth to offset the risk that the market may one day reduce Palantir’s valuation to a lower level.
The stakes of this $185 dispute are instructive.
According to Wall Street reports, Palantir is growing into a major artificial intelligence software company. The open question is how much investors have already paid for future success.
Related: Palantir CEO Just Called Old-school Software Sales Model “Dead”