It’s increasingly difficult for Americans to ignore the gap between cooking and ordering food.
The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that restaurant prices increased 3.5% in September compared with the same month last year. While limited-service meals, which include most fast-food restaurants and drive-thru restaurants, increased 3.2%, full-service meals increased 3.8%.
The rise in grocery prices is more subtle. In September, household food costs actually fell by 0.1% and were only 1.8% higher than the previous year.
Since wages in the U.S. have also not kept pace with overall inflation, this growing gap is huge.
Although consumer prices rose by 3.7%, average hourly wages increased by only 3% from the previous year. Adjusted for inflation, real hourly wages fell 0.7% annually and 0.5% from August to September, leaving customers with less money to spend.
for McDonald’s (MCD), Yum Brands (YUM), Domino’s Pizza (DPZ)and other restaurant stocks, turning affordability into something more important than a marketing slogan. It is becoming one of the most important obstacles to the growth of the industry.
Restaurant prices continue to exceed grocery prices
The rapid increase in restaurant prices helps explain why a cheap dinner that once cost $10 or $15 at a restaurant is now worth more at a supermarket.
Grocery stores absorb different costs than restaurants. In addition to the meals themselves, there’s labor, rent, utilities, insurance and delivery. Rising energy and natural gas prices have added to the pressure.
Ultimately, customers see the cost on the menu.
Nation’s Restaurant News noted that restaurant inflation is now well ahead of grocery inflation; at the same time, wages have failed to keep pace with broader increases in consumer prices.
Home cooking has always faced competition from fast food restaurants due to price and convenience. If the price gap between groceries and drive-thru meals continues to widen, restaurants are in danger of losing half their business.
McDonald’s has previously acknowledged the difficulty.
McDonald’s warned in September that continued inflation could leave restaurant traffic essentially flat in major markets. it launched a US$8.5 billion, ten-year plan According to Reuters, the program is designed in part to help franchisees improve economics and attract repeat customers.
McDonald’s is also leaning heavily on its McValue platform, including its under-$3 menu and $4 breakfast deals.
The message is clear: Even the world’s largest restaurant companies can’t lose their mindset on pricing.
Alexander Zubkov/Getty Images
Restaurants are struggling to maintain the value equation
Even though consumers are becoming pickier about what they buy, they haven’t stopped eating out.
As a result, chain restaurants are not only lowering overall menu prices but are increasingly offering reduced portion sizes, packaged meals and temporary discounts.
The smaller Go Buckets have been tested by KFC. Domino’s has shifted its focus to promotions and small deals. To make the per-capita cost more apparent, some merchants emphasize family meals or value packages.
There’s a clear commonality among restaurants trying to maintain traffic without sacrificing too much profit.
More restaurants:
- Hooters Restaurants closes more restaurants as bankruptcy comes back
- These are the real gourmet kitchen spots that closed in Chapter 11
- Oprah-backed chain permanently closes 12 restaurants after filing Chapter 11 bankruptcy
Achieving this balance can be challenging. A cheap dinner might entice someone in, but they might pass up a drink, side, or dessert that could increase the profit on the order.
Therefore, restaurant investors must consider factors beyond overall comparable sales growth.
Even if fewer customers actually visit the restaurant, same-store sales are likely to increase due to higher menu pricing. Order volume, traffic and promotional spend are becoming more important indicators of a company’s health.
McDonald’s continues to emphasize affordability, despite reporting positive comparable sales. Taco Bell’s ability to maintain a strong value image also helps it outperform other fast-food restaurants.
This difference may become increasingly important.
Customers are not necessarily demanding lower restaurant prices. They need to feel like the meal is worth the extra cost compared to what they would eat at home.
Drive-thru now must justify its premium
Restaurants are not at risk of Americans suddenly giving up eating out. Instead, the challenge is that cheaper options become more competitive at every meal.
This decision will become increasingly obvious if grocery inflation is lower than restaurant inflation. When a family sees a $35 or $40 fast food order, they can start comparing it to a meal they might buy at a grocery store instead of another restaurant.
If a restaurant chain has a strong loyalty program, unique cuisine, a convenient location, or a very high value perception, they may be able to increase costs without significantly reducing customer traffic.
The problem is that smaller restaurants often lack sophisticated digital loyalty systems, large advertising budgets and the massive buying power of chains like McDonald’s and Domino’s.
What’s most striking to me is that fast food is losing some of the psychological edge that made it so successful.
In the past, drive-ins were a convenient alternative to dining at full-service restaurants. But customers now have to decide whether that convenience is worth paying a much higher price than groceries.
One metric will be particularly important for restaurant investors in the coming quarters: whether customers will come back.
RELATED: McDonald’s menu appears to have price problem