Family of Franklin High School student who died at school files damages claim

The family of Xavier Nungaray-Martinez has filed a damages claim against the Los Angeles School District over the recent on-campus death of the 17-year-old Franklin High senior.

A formal statement of claims is scheduled to be released Monday, but details were released over the weekend, with attorneys releasing copies of documents they filed with the Los Angeles Unified School District.

Such claims are often brought as an early step leading to litigation. The documents seek unspecified damages.

Xavier’s mother and father are represented by separate law firms. Each company brings claims on behalf of the parent company it represents.

The charges accuse the district of widespread negligence, allowing dangerous conditions to develop on the Highland Park campus and violating its legal duty to protect the students in its care.

Xavier’s mother, Lilia Paola Nungaray, claims that “the Los Angeles Unified School District knew or should have known that Xavier was bullied by other students at Franklin High School and knew or should have known about the attacker’s aggressive and violent tendencies through staff observations, prior incidents, disciplinary records, counselor contacts and other available information.”

The statement also noted that Xavier and his mother “met with Franklin High School administrators regarding another bullying incident that occurred during Xavier’s sophomore year. School administration partially blamed Xavier for the previous incident.”

A similar statement was made by the father.

“Los Angeles Unified School District staff and the administration of Benjamin Franklin High School were notified in advance of the lack of appropriate supervision of students,” claimed the father, William Amaya, who listed Xavier by his last name, Amaya. “The Los Angeles Unified School District and its administrators knew that Xavier … was being bullied before he was brutally beaten” and “did nothing to protect him” [him] From this bully or other bullies. “

Los Angeles Unified did not immediately respond to The Times on Sunday night, but a spokesperson told The California Post that it does not respond to “pending or ongoing litigation.”

On September 30, Xavier was beaten multiple times in the classroom by another student, then ran out the door and fell from a fourth-floor railing as the student who beat him appeared to be approaching quickly. All of this was captured on widely circulated cell phone footage, but it did not capture the events leading up to the alleged attack.

Both accounts describe some elements of the alleged sequence of events in greater detail than the publicly available footage.

According to the mother, “while students were having lunch,” a student attacked Xavier, “hit him in the face, knocked him to the ground, and continued to beat him while he was on the ground. A classmate directly behind them saw another student repeatedly punch Xavier. Xavier did not fight back.”

In interviews with The Times, some students and parents expressed concern about bullying, while others said it was rare or no more serious than at other high schools.

The mother’s account also noted that the teacher in the room did not immediately separate the students, call for help or follow up to ensure Xavier did not suffer further harm.

The father’s account said the head teacher was a substitute teacher – something other members of the school community said in interviews.

Cell phone footage previously seen by The Times showed the older man, the teacher, yelling at the alleged attacker to stop before standing between the students to separate them. In the film, the attacker delivers a final blow to Xavier, who is turned away, knocking him out. Xavier then stumbled quickly out of the room. His jump from the balcony appeared to occur only for a few seconds and was captured on another mobile phone video.

“The blow to Xavier’s head, as well as the fear, panic and confusion caused by the attack, left him dizzy and disoriented… and as a direct result of the attack, he climbed over the railing,” the mother’s statement said.

“The beating caused Xavier Amaya to run away from the bully in what appeared to be an attempt to escape… which caused Xavier Amaya to fall… resulting in his tragic and untimely death,” the father’s statement said.

The county medical examiner’s office ruled that Xavier’s death was a suicide, but the family disputed that conclusion before filing their claim.

The mother’s claim is dated October 15 and signed by attorneys Spencer R. Lucas and Alec M. Clark. The father’s claim is dated November 13 and signed by attorney Luis A. Carrillo.

The Los Angeles Police Department has released little information about its ongoing investigation into Xavier’s death, saying it is looking into allegations that “bullying may be one of them.” No arrests have been made.

Leave a Comment